It hasn’t gone away you know
Author: NiamhIt hasn’t gone away you know. The debate on death row rumbles on. Now there are calls in England for re-introducing the death penalty there. They follow in the wake of a particularly gruesome murder. Yet the question remains what would re-introducing the death penalty actually achieve?
For some people, of course, it would be a kind of revenge, especially if a loved one of theirs had been harmed or killed. On the other hand they might remember the words of Benjamin Franklin who said, ‘Tis more noble to forgive, and more manly to despise, than to revenge an Injury.”
Certainly murderers have to be punished. Certainly society has to be kept safe from them. What sort of society, though, hangs, shoots and electrocutes prisoners? It must surely be one that has never heard of rehabilitation or of Christian forgiveness.
Keeping people on death row for years is inhumane. The fact that they have committed dreadful crimes doesn’t take away from the fact that a prison system that keeps them there awaiting a grisly death is a crime in itself. There can be no doubt too but that some of them are innocent and many of them have mental problems which deserve medical treatment. After all what kind of normal person commits crimes of this sort?
Prison is not the only punishment for crime. Murderers and rapists who are a threat to others certainly need to be locked up but perhaps in a different environment than prison. Certainly we should be doing our best to ensure that they develop the work ethic and that they have the opportunity to learn how to become productive. Uninhabited islands might be used where farming methods could be taught. They might be put to doing some work in undeveloped countries. The death penalty certainly kills some of those who are dangers to society but others quickly take their place because society hasn’t tackled the social problems they breed the law of the jungle. Nor has it given them the message that they can become better people. Every time we execute a prisoner we are killing our own humanity.
Check out our sample speeches


